Who's your favorite kit manufactuer :: Experiences and /or reviews of model kits :: Ship Modeling Forum
Click here to view the full size Ship Modeling Forum Logo Ship Modeling Forum @ shipmodeling.net - A web site forum devoted to the handcrafting of model ships and boats

Click here for Quick Navigation
This site is a member of the Ship Modeler's Calm Seas Guild
Hello Guest! There's a lot to look over, so sit back with a cup of coffee, relax and browse around. We have a great group of ship and boat modelers here, both newbies and old salts, from all over the world. Our goal here is to help each other, without criticism or rebuke. Both newbies and old salts alike can learn from each other. No one has all the answers. Our most basic rule is simple, respect for your fellow members and their opinions. And don't take yourself too seriously! wirewolf (John, AKA - Cap), Forum Administrator
"I only found this forum a month ago and already it has been a lot of help. Many thanks to all." - Pugwash (Guy)
"Signing up on the forum was one of my best moves in modeling that I made and I am sure you will soon agree." - chhbmd (Charlie)
"I can't tell you how much I enjoy coming aboard each day and looking at the material on this site." Read More... - oodygdin (Richard)

Get Firefox - Take Back the Web  Announcing the Winners in the 2008 Ship Modeling Forum's Model Competition!

Go Back   Return to the Forums' Main Page > General Discussion Forums: > Experiences and /or reviews of model kits
Username Password
Problems Logging In - Click Here
Register Users' Guide Projects List Calendar Current Posts Site Map

View Poll Results: Vote for your favorite Kit Manufactuer
Anfora 0 0%
Amati 7 2.97%
Artesania Latina 36 15.25%
Constructo 10 4.24%
Corel 22 9.32%
Dumas 4 1.69%
Euro Model 2 0.85%
Mamoli 11 4.66%
Mantua 11 4.66%
Midwest 8 3.39%
Model Shipways 75 31.78%
Soclaine 0 0%
BlueJacket 18 7.63%
Sergal 4 1.69%
Calder Craft 28 11.86%
Voters: 236. You may not vote on this poll

Share this Thread Thread Tools Search this Thread
Old 01-13-2004, 04:01 PM
Click here to see this member's profile
yukyo's Avatar
yukyo yukyo is offline
Join Date: Dec 2003
Current Project: None at present
Project Status: Researching new project
Location: Tokyo
Posts: 19
Default

I'm starting a poll on "Who's Kits do you like the most?"
If you like, post a reply message here after you vote, and explain what is it you like or don't like about about certain kits. Please don't start a new topic.
If I forgot a manufactuer, just let me know. I'll add them to the list.

View this Members' Articles / Shop Notes  
 
 
  Searching for something? See Search Tips, Main Search Page, Amazon Quick Search
Do a "Quickie" - Google that is!  Or would you rather - "Amazon"
Old 01-30-2004, 12:07 PM
Click here to see this member's profile
Pat's Avatar
Click here to view this Members' Photo Gallery
Pat's latest photo
firstmate (Pat) firstmate is offline
Join Date: Dec 2003
Current Project: Model Shipways Whaleboat
Project Status: Hull done, but haven't had much time lately
Location: Canada
Posts: 191
Default

I don't know about the rest of you, but I've always been partial to Model Shipways Kits. The instructions are usually well written and the plans are well done. If I don't care for some of the cast parts that come with a kit, I'll make my own to suit.

------------Members' Signature------------
Old Carpenters' saying - "Measure twice, Cut once"
Model Shipwrights - "Measure three, four.....Cut, Fit three, four....., glue and pray once"

View this Members' Photo Gallery View this Members' Articles / Shop Notes View this Members' Links View this Members' Glossary Terms  
 
 
  Searching for something? See Search Tips, Main Search Page, Amazon Quick Search
Do a "Quickie" - Google that is!  Or would you rather - "Amazon"
Old 01-30-2004, 12:42 PM
Click here to see this member's profile
prospect's Avatar
prospect prospect is offline
Join Date: Dec 2003
Current Project: Boothbay Lobster Boat, Midwest
Project Status: Almost Done. Deciding to make it R/C or not
Location: USA
Posts: 16
Default

Always liked Midwest and Model Shipways kits. A lot of the kits from Europe don't have very clear instructions, and sometimes the parts they give you don't seem the fit the era of the ship.

 
 
 
  Searching for something? See Search Tips, Main Search Page, Amazon Quick Search
Do a "Quickie" - Google that is!  Or would you rather - "Amazon"
Old 01-30-2004, 11:16 PM
Click here to see this member's profile
Steve's Avatar
sabah (Steve) sabah is offline
Join Date: Jan 2004
Current Project: Looking at various kits
Project Status: Researching new project
Location: USA
Posts: 68
Default

I have found most of the European kits to, well, not to be so good. If I do get one I have to go through it and change or remake a lot of the parts (mostly the cast ones). I don't do entire scratch models, but I will modify kits so they will be more historically accurate. As I said in another post, I like to research a ship as much as possible prior to starting construction.

View this Members' Photo Gallery View this Members' Articles / Shop Notes View this Members' Links View this Members' Glossary Terms  
 
 
  Searching for something? See Search Tips, Main Search Page, Amazon Quick Search
Do a "Quickie" - Google that is!  Or would you rather - "Amazon"
Old 02-12-2004, 09:13 AM
Click here to see this member's profile
Kevin's Avatar
plankowner (Kevin) plankowner is offline
Join Date: Feb 2004
Current Project: None right now
Project Status: Researching new project
Location: Right behind you!
Posts: 70
Default

Tried a few of the kits from Europe. But if I had my choice, I'd stick with Dumas or Model Shipways. I've also bashed some kits, used the basic parts and semi scratch built my own. I don't get down to making my own blocks and such. I'll order small parts like that from one of the hobby suppliers online. My local hobby shop (as with most) doesn't carry much in the way of ship parts.

View this Members' Photo Gallery View this Members' Links  
 
 
  Searching for something? See Search Tips, Main Search Page, Amazon Quick Search
Do a "Quickie" - Google that is!  Or would you rather - "Amazon"
Old 02-12-2004, 03:03 PM
blulion blulion is offline
Join Date: Dec 2003
Current Project: Amati kit of the Bluenose
Project Status: Work in progress
Location: USA
Posts: 18
Default

Not much to say. This is my first foray into ships. I did model airplanes in the past. I'm working on the Bluenose by Amati right now. I have nothing to compare it to, but the translations could be a little better. Let you know more when I finish the model.

 
 
 
  Searching for something? See Search Tips, Main Search Page, Amazon Quick Search
Do a "Quickie" - Google that is!  Or would you rather - "Amazon"
Old 02-14-2004, 01:12 PM
Click here to see this member's profile
David's Avatar
Click here to view this Members' Photo Gallery
David's latest photo
dhartwick (David) dhartwick is offline
Join Date: Feb 2004
Current Project: MS Constitution
Project Status: Taking a break
Location: Pittsburgh, PA
Posts: 361
Default

Being new to the wooden side of ship modeling I can't make an honest choice. But this is valuable info for selecting a kit. It lessens the chances of getting in over one's head right of the bat and causing discouragement with the hobby.

------------Members' Signature------------
"With the knowledge of hindsight, they were a piratical-looking crew." C. Alexander

Currently: MS USS Constitution
Finished: MS Bluenose 1921, AL Clara May,
AL Open Hull HMAV Bounty
My pipe dream: Graduate to scratch building

View this Members' Photo Gallery View this Members' Articles / Shop Notes View this Members' Links View this Members' Glossary Terms  
 
 
  Searching for something? See Search Tips, Main Search Page, Amazon Quick Search
Do a "Quickie" - Google that is!  Or would you rather - "Amazon"
Old 02-16-2004, 11:32 AM
Click here to see this member's profile
David's Avatar
Click here to view this Members' Photo Gallery
David's latest photo
dhartwick (David) dhartwick is offline
Join Date: Feb 2004
Current Project: MS Constitution
Project Status: Taking a break
Location: Pittsburgh, PA
Posts: 361
Default

Hi tobee,
I've started the Model shipways Virginia Sloop and have the Bluenose waitng in the wings. The most difficult problem to date was getting the permission from my wife to take up space in "her" work area, LOL!

These two models look perfect for my first trek up Mt. Everest. Although, I do have some rigging experience with plastic models Cutty Sark and Constitution which turned out tobee respectible.

------------Members' Signature------------
"With the knowledge of hindsight, they were a piratical-looking crew." C. Alexander

Currently: MS USS Constitution
Finished: MS Bluenose 1921, AL Clara May,
AL Open Hull HMAV Bounty
My pipe dream: Graduate to scratch building

View this Members' Photo Gallery View this Members' Articles / Shop Notes View this Members' Links View this Members' Glossary Terms  
 
 
  Searching for something? See Search Tips, Main Search Page, Amazon Quick Search
Do a "Quickie" - Google that is!  Or would you rather - "Amazon"